Guarding the Constitution in Silence: How Judges Experience Independence Under Executive Pressure

Sari, Retno Dewi Pulung (2025) Guarding the Constitution in Silence: How Judges Experience Independence Under Executive Pressure. Hukmuna: Journal of Law and Policy, 1 (6). pp. 234-241. ISSN 3089-6460

Text 451 Restricted to Repository staff only Download (35kB)

Abstract

Judicial independence is a cornerstone of constitutional law, especially in transitional democracies where political pressures challenge institutional integrity. While prior research has examined legal frameworks and formal safeguards, there is limited understanding of how constitutional judges personally experience and interpret independence in the face of executive influence. This study addresses that gap by investigating how judges perceive and navigate judicial independence under political pressure. Employing an interpretative phenomenological approach, the research focuses on the lived experiences of eight constitutional judges, collected through in-depth semi-structured interviews and analyzed using Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA). Three key themes emerged: institutional isolation, moral struggle, and silent resistance. These findings suggest that judicial independence is not merely a legal principle, but a personal and context-driven process shaped by emotional and ethical considerations. The study contributes to constitutional scholarship by revealing the inner dimensions of judicial decision-making and offers new insights into how judges maintain autonomy in politically charged environments.

Item Type:	Article
Uncontrolled Keywords:	Judicial Independence, Constitutional Adjudication, Political Pressure, Judicial Ethics, Interpretive Analysis, Lived Experience, Constitutional Judges
Subjects:	K Law > K Law (General)
Divisions:	Fakultas Hukum > Prodi Ilmu Hukum
Depositing User:	Retno Dewi Pulungsari
Date Deposited:	25 Feb 2026 02:20
Last Modified:	25 Feb 2026 02:20
URI:	http://repositori.ukdc.ac.id/id/eprint/2523

Actions (login required)

View Item